Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts

Saturday, October 29, 2016

Why are Indian lawyers more businessmen than professionals

Recently, I had read books on the medical profession such as http://www.amazon.in/Dissenting-Diagnosis-Arun-Gadre/dp/8184007019?ie=UTF8&keywords=Dissenting%20Diagnosis&qid=1477762824&ref_=sr_1_1&s=digital-text&sr=8-1  and http://www.amazon.in/Ethical-Doctor-Kamal-Kumar-Mahawar/dp/9352640098/ref=pd_sim_14_6?  _encoding=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=1CTG40KCX9RYQRE0FVWW
This got me thinking about other professions including law, and therefore this law. The reason I write about law is the importance of it in the growing litigious environment amidst the legal shambles. No other profession gets such negative coverage, be it the advocates agitation/strikes, 'tareek pe tareek'..While reading about this topic, I saw that the list of misconducts cited in the below article is mind boggling
http://www.legalservicesindia.com/article/article/professional-misconduct-of-lawyers-in-india-1665-1.html

Without much ado, I proceed to my grouses
  1. ·         Advocates strikes/hartals/bandhs-even at the cost of their clients 
  2.  ·         The culture of adjournments
  3.  ·         ‘Eternal’ arbitrations
  4.  ·         Probono very care, legal services cell hardly in vogue
  5.  ·         Preferential treatment to Senior Counsel-unjustified that their reputation is formalized and fee earning capacity enhanced, by the result of a opaque process without any continuing obligation
  6.  ·         Too much separation of work-Advocate, Solicitor, Counsel-many folks to pay fees
  7.  ·         Limited effort to insert ‘Plain English’ in drafting
  8.  ·         No scale of fees/standard rate chart-


Remedies
  1. ·         Startups to assess win/loss odds like in UK basis type of matter, number and outcome of hearings, case status(upheld/overturned)-This is a formal assessment of succcess rate and efficiency which could help for mass litigation matters
  2.  ·         Automate ‘routine’ stuff like legal contracts-This while reducing bread/butter business, would help lawyers do more value adding work
  3.  ·         ADR allowing for other professionals such as CA/CS/CWA, who are regulated more strictly
  4.       Simplication of laws, procedures and court/police procedures, so that the common man can represent himself/herself in court and largely via written submissions 
  5.      Restriction on # of matters a lawyer can take at a time(~ceiling on tax audits of CA) so that the culture of adjourments reduces
  6.      Court Management Introduction to address delays in proceedings     


Thursday, March 15, 2012

Indian Legal System-root of all political and economic evils

In an era where the Supreme Court is the 'last man standing' when it comes to institutional integrity, this post may seem weird. But the Supreme Court does not reflect system at large. There are other reasons for the evils like police being under State control etc but this post focusses on the legal reasons.
  1. Law is too complex for laypersons to understand. While one cannot simplify the law beyond a point and that is why we need experts, there is a case for legal inclusion(demystifying the law) similar to financial inclusions
  2. Too many procedures make subordinate courts hot bed of corruption-this is true for getting certified copies, hearing dates and other small things. 
  3. Criminals are our elected legislators and pending cases take time-this is a root cause for criminalization of politics. While one must admit that people are presumed innocent unless proven guilty, there should be a self censorship for serial offenders. 
  4. Senior Advocates rarely take probono cases/PILs and milk the title for charging higher fees. Nothing wrong with that from business standpoint, but why should someone use a public office(like Senior Advocate) for private benefit in terms of fees? But if someone uses a lesser known advocate, judicial officers may not give them a fair hearing in the era of uncle judges.
  5. Our worst functioning and scam ridden markets like real estate, mining are because of legal imperfections in land registry, government regulation etc.
  6. Our judges work quite hard(in any terms, hours worked/judgements passed etc) compared to international standards and for much lower pay, but this is not showing up in the backlog. 
  7. Thanks to multiple adjournments and other dilatory tactics causing the backlog to pile up even more,  lawyers can rack up their per hearing fee(since the Bar Council does not permit contingency fees that would give incentive to finish the case fast). While tax laws have the 3 adjournment limit, this is yet to be applied for other laws. Sunny Deol's famous 3min monologue in the film Damini 'Tareekh pe Tareekh' is still relevant today.
  8. Courts still interpret laws assuming that the legislature knows the law/acts in the interest of the public etc, but in an era where laws are passed without debate and with little scrutiny even by House Committees, where Opposition views are steamrollered, should not the principles of interpretation be thought over again?

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Where the Supreme Court covered itself with shame

While legal luminaries will doubtless have many more incidents to recall, the recency effect limits me only to cases I've stumbled across. To avoid any contempt of court action(!), let me just say that this is a critique of the judgements, not of the institution itself which has delivered several landmark verdicts over its lifespam, especially in the last few years. The reason I'm stating this is to show that nobody is infalliable
  1. SDM Jabalpur Case:- This was an Emergency era case which dealt with the rights of the Government to subject a person to preventive detention. And contrary to its stand before and after Emergency, the Supreme Court then sided with the Government in curtailing individual liberties.
  2. RTI appeal before the Supreme Court:-A petitioner had sought information from the Supreme Court via RTI. The Chief Administrative official of the Supreme Court('Registrar') opposed that, lost the battle before the chief RTI authority(CIC), and then took up the case before the Delhi High Court, fully aware that even if he lost, it would come up before the Supreme Court. The fact that the judges even allowed this to happen, does not reflect well on them.
  3. Delhi 'illegal premises' sealing case:-While the Supreme Court took the moral high ground of taking a stance against illegal realty development, that order came as a shocker, and later it was revealed that the sons of the Chief Justice gained substantially in their realty holdings because of the sudden supply constraint. Again, this was a case where appearances mattered, and the least the judge could have done was to have excused himself from the case. 
  4. Raj Narain vs State of UP(the election fraud case): The UP HC judge had held Indira Gandhi guilty of misusing government machinery(therefore 'election fraud') and debarred her from contesting elections for 6 years. The following furore partly stoked unrest and Emergency was declared in June, 1975, with Indira Gandhi still the Prime Minister. Yet, the Supreme Court did not seek an independent atmosphere/status quo before reversing the verdict and confirming Indira Gandhi's prime ministership. Without going into the legal merits, it is doubtful how a verdict against the incubent prime minister under Emergency conditions, could have been 'free and fair'.
These are just 4 stray cases in 60yrs, so I guess we should consider ourselves lucky compared to other countries. 

Saturday, August 20, 2011

Organizations enforcing commercial laws((YouTube's triple strike ban policy)-is this fair?

Internet is a nearly costless(on incremental cost basis) distribution method, and amenable to use by digital goods industries(media, software, information etc). The relative anonymity and ease of use, provided by internet(relative to other media/distribution channels) enables impulse purchases, but also allows for easy piracy. The music records industry was decimated by Napster(and later Apple itunes), the book publishing/distribution industry is in decline(witness the decline of Borders and the upswing of Amazon/Apple) and other industries(movies, gaming, software) seem destined to go the same way. While some are cleverly averting it with the mantra of cloud computing-where users must operate in a controlled environment where piracy is no longer possible-others are taking legal shield, compelling others to enforce the laws for them.

Take for example YouTube. It does not actively encourage uploads of pirated content. But if copyright owners successfully report pirated content repeatedly, the offending user's account is subject to deletion. There are some safeguards here, that if the user contests the piracy claim, the copyright owner must sue in the courts of law. But given the legal expenses, individual users would mostly not have the will/resources to contest those suits, and may lose. One may argue that thievery cannot be condoned, and that Youtube is justified in ensuing that its users do not use its network to break the law

But taken to its logical conclusion, this argument is dangerous. No organization has clean hands, and some or the other offence/violation/ethical breach would have been committed. If a vigilante takes up those breaches in its hands and decides to mete out instant justice, where would those organizations be? Yet, such justice is conceptually no way different from organizations voluntarily enforcing other's IP. As a ISP like platform provider, Youtube's obligation is at best to delete the offending files. Deleting account access is an extreme step. Such issues will become more important when internet/Google are recognized as essential services.